Choosing an eCommerce agency in the age of AI
Evaluate a paid-media partner by commercial expertise, account ownership and measurement—not simply its use of AI.
Short answer
AI adoption alone is not a meaningful distinction between agencies. Assess whether the proposed team understands your economics, category and operational constraints. Ask how it measures additional growth, manages creative and feeds, and converts analysis into decisions. The relevant expertise belongs to the people actually working on the account.
Key takeaways
- Access to AI tools is not evidence of eCommerce expertise.
- Evaluate the assigned team rather than only the sales presentation.
- Ask for decision examples and commercial reasoning.
Move beyond the technology pitch
Faster reporting and lower administrative effort are useful, but they do not establish that a partner can grow a D2C business profitably. A generalist may have excellent capability; a specialist label may also overstate the depth of the team. Evaluate evidence rather than agency categories alone.
Relevant experience includes product margins, average order value, returns, customer retention and inventory—not just knowledge of advertising interfaces.
Assess the operating model
Understand who makes decisions, how often the team reviews the commercial picture and what happens when platform reports conflict with store performance.
- Ask who owns the account and how many accounts they manage.
- Review feed management, creative testing and conversion handoffs.
- Ask how the team handles tracking failures and scaling constraints.
- Request an example of rejecting a platform recommendation for a commercial reason.
Buy better judgement, not more dashboards
A strong partner uses automation to make more time for diagnosis, creative direction and commercial planning. The value should be visible in the quality of decisions and the learning process, not simply in the volume of generated reports.
FAQ
Is a specialist agency always better than a generalist?
No. Relevant expertise, staffing and the operating process matter more than the label. Choose the team that can demonstrate understanding of your business and explain how its decisions connect to profitable growth.
Want this run on your own account?
Request a free ad account audit. We review tracking, account structure, creative mix and wasted spend, and send back a prioritised 90-day plan within 48–72 hours of getting access.